If they take Gabbert or Newton its 100% definitely not a reach. Most Reputable draft analysts have both ranked in the top 10, many in the top 5. If you need a QB and you pick someone ranked in the top 10 with #3 pick, its not a reach. Original question is poorly worded.
2011 - Smart posters warned everyone else, Fitzpatrick was a waste of a year. Now we all know.
2012 - Smart posters warned everyone else another season of Gailey was a waste of a year. Now we all know
2013 - Smart posters are warning everyone else another year of brandon/nix is a waste of a year. Next year we will all know.