Spencer Johnson or Dwan Edwards?

[BillsMafia#1]

Looks like we have a too many DT's on this team. I don't think Kellen Heard even has a chance and imo Troup and Carrington are locks along with Dareus and Williams. So which one is the odd man out Johnson or Edwards? Both make pretty good money and i think its pretty close. I have seen flases from both but have also seen both disappear. So which one would u keep if u were Nix?

[sjhbillsfan]

I still think you could trade Dwan to a 3-4 team like, for example, Indi that just started one with a former Ravens coach.

I don't think Dwan is probably better, but Johnson has more experience in a 4-3.

That being said, if you run a 4-3 you are going to want keep at least 5 maybe 6 tackles and I wouldn't be shocked if it is 6 we are keeping them both.

K. Williams
Dareus
Troup
Carrington
Edwards
Johnson

[MOVETHECHAINS]

Edwards all the way, I never have been a fan of Sp. Johnson.

[Jm2009]

Edwards is better to keep.

[RTLong]

Johnson can play both end and tackle so I'd keep him since he'd likely be depth for both. In this defense Edwards is a tackle. Plus he counts against the cap for longer than Johnson.

[Te_Puru]

Johnson is suited to our 43 defense. Dwan is a pure 5 tech DE for a 34.

BOTH are expensive.

[BirchBigsley]

Trade Dwan for a 6th or 7th rounder to Indy. I doubt he'd get a 6th but ya never know. We could always trade McKelvin to Indy as well. Indy needs CBs bad.

[we are]

Players like dwan Edwards are not tradable...he's 30+ years old and pretty much a dime a dozen type player.

I'd rather keep Johnson...more 43 experience and more versatile.