Who is the better Qb?

[o Cj o0]

Vince Young is the gamer we need to make a playoff push. IMO Vince is a wayyyyy better Qb Than Fitz. What do you guys think??

[rickyray]

Everyone outside of Buffalo knows Young is the better Qb.Its the blind homers here who think a certified career back like Fitz really strikes fear in any defenses and is a franchise starter...

You do a nation wide poll on who is the better QB,regardless of Youngs past garbage and the results would be 85% to 15% in Vince Young's favor.

[Magnum33]

Vince Young is the gamer we need to make a playoff push. IMO Vince is a wayyyyy better Qb Than Fitz. What do you guys think??

Based off of what stat? His failed attempt at starting for the Titans or his failed attempt at being a back up for the Eagles??

[hemma]

..... just when things were starting to go well.

[TheWien]

Isn't there already a Poll on this sticky'd? Can we close this trap?

[o Cj o0]

Based off of what stat? His failed attempt at starting for the Titans or his failed attempt at being a back up for the Eagles??

How about His National Tiltle, or top 5 draft status, his better win % , He is taller, stronger arm, more mobile the list goes on.....

[o Cj o0]

Isn't there already a Poll on this sticky'd? Can we close this trap?

Maybe just maybe I didnt see a poll like this. I actually have a life.

[Magnum33]

How about His National Tiltle, or top 5 draft status, his better win % , He is taller, stronger arm, more mobile the list goes on.....

Oh sweet, lets get Leinart then!!! Heck, lets bail out Leaf and grab him!!

[wppete]

Better Question is who is better Vice Young or Tyler Thigpen????

IMO Vince Young would be a great Back Up and come in on special packages. Gives us another threat.

[CPTBobby2]

How about His National Tiltle, or top 5 draft status, his better win % , He is taller, stronger arm, more mobile the list goes on.....

His 57.9% completion percentage

His horrible TD to INT ratio. INTs more.

40 career fumbles

[o Cj o0]

15-6 Im shocked at the majority of votes going fitzpatrick....... Then again no im not

[TrevorBills]

Easy to see Fitz is he has gotten better while every year VY gets worse. Vince has more INT's then TD's more fumbles lost, lower completion %. With all you guys screaming this is a passing league I cant see how anyone would say VY is good.

[o Cj o0]

His 57.9% completion percentage

His horrible TD to INT ratio. INTs more.

40 career fumbles

30-19 as a Starter you cant take that away from him. You also have to take into account his ability to run, gives opposing D's something extra to think about.

[bilzfancy]

the Eagles would rather have Trent Edwards then VY, what the hell does that tell you?

[AxionJaxionMVP]

How about His National Tiltle, or top 5 draft status, his better win % , He is taller, stronger arm, more mobile the list goes on.....

Complete bs. National title? Whats he done title wise at the pro level? Taller? yeah a whopping 2 inches big whoop. Stronger arm? Yeah marginally but Fitz has displayed better accuracy and has PLENTY of arm(see 98 yard TD to T.O.) Mobility? Fitz has displayed very good mobility as well.

There isn't a big gap in athleticism and Fitz is FAR more intelligent and a whole lot more mature. Fitz also plays with a lot more heart.

[V-Expression]

15-6 Im shocked at the majority of votes going fitzpatrick....... Then again no im not

Turns out 75% of BBMB members might actually be intelligent.

And 25% are not, and are likely to start threads saying VY is better than Fitzpatrick...

[CPTBobby2]

Like said before

Bills Fitz>Edwards
Eagles Edwards>Young
Bills Fans Young>Fitz

[o Cj o0]

the Eagles would rather have Trent Edwards then VY, what the hell does that tell you?

Eagles would rather have Trent hold a clip board insted of Vince. Trent Edwards will NEVER see the field in philly.

[Darkside02]

To much pressure,I couldn't vote

[o Cj o0]

Turns out 75% of BBMB members might actually be intelligent.

And 25% are not, and are likely to start threads saying VY is better than Fitzpatrick...